See all 31 houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY, including affordable, luxury and pet-friendly rentals. Set filters to find pet friendly, cheap, luxury, furnished, no deposit, low income, or places with move-in specials for your next house near Shelter Island, NY. RE Broker (631) 749-0800, Griffing & Collins Real Estate (631) 749-0500, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 329-9400, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (917) 664-3017, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 354-8100, Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 537-7105, Coldwell Banker Beau Hulse Realty Group (631) 287-7707, Nest Seekers International (631) 353-3427, Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty (631) 749-1155, Trulia is a registered Trademark of Zillow, Inc. and MLS listings are provided by Zillow, Inc., a licensed real estate brokerage. While most of Shelter Island’s beaches require a permit to park a car, if you’re not a local and don’t want to spring for the fee, you can either rent a bike at Piccozzi’s Bike Shop or make a … Search these Shelter Island Rentals. 7 Beds, 8.5 Baths. Houses For Rent in Shelter Island, NY 56 rentals available on Trulia Home for rent. M. Join / Log In. Choose from more than 2,000 properties, ideal house rentals for families, groups and couples. Shelter Island… With more than 1 million active listings all across the country, Apartments.com can help you find the perfect NY house for rent near you. Sunny & Serene Private Cottage near Downtown EH Our lovely one-bedroom cottage sits on a quiet lane 3/4 of a … We found 19 Houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY. Search 73 Rental Properties in Shelter Island, New York. … Or sign in if you already have an account. - Page 2 Open Floor Plan For living. See all 50 apartments and houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY, including cheap, affordable, luxury and pet-friendly rentals. View photos, property details and find the perfect rental today. Preferences. Sales Rentals Land Stories Guides Open Houses Careers Press Help $2,400. Shelter Island, NY houses for rent and MLS Listings. Explore an array of Shelter Island, NY vacation rentals, including houses, cottages & more bookable online. View prices, photos, virtual tours, floor plans, amenities, pet policies, rent specials, property details and availability for apartments at 57 N Menantic Rd Rental on ForRent.com. Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage can help you find Shelter Island homes for sale and rentals.. room, Din. Each Apartments.com listing has verified availability, rental rates, photos, floor plans and more. Find shelter island properties for rent at the best price Shelter Island, NY Houses for Rent Shelter Island is a terrific choice for your new house. Home for rent. Shelter Island’s rental homes generally offer quick access to the community’s many beaches as well as the locally owned shops and restaurants that line Ferry Road. See 19 Houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY, browse photos, floor plans, reviews and more to help you find your perfect home. Shelter Island is also roughly a two-hour drive from New York City. Beautiful Shelter Island home available for rent! Check out RentDigs.com! Please try again later. 1 day ago. We have 240 properties for rent listed as shelter island apartment, from just $599. Refine your Shelter Island rental search results by price, property type, bedrooms, baths and other features. Explore an array of Shelter Island, NY vacation rentals, including houses, cottages & more bookable online. Check Availability. Nicknamed “the un-Hamptons,” Shelter Island is a peaceful island community situated on the eastern end of Long Island. 3 beds. ... 6 homes for rent in Shelter Island. An established leader in Shelter Island real estate for over 20 years, M Wein Realty Inc has the real estate agency experience and expertise to help you find or sell the perfect property on Shelter Island House Rentals in Shelter Island: View Tripadvisor's 255 unbiased reviews, 1,940 photos and great deals on Shelter Island House Rentals 2 Bathrooms. Charming cottage with screened in porch … Shelter Island : $45,000 RRN: 19-L-0119. $10k. 1024.5 Isabella Ave, Coronado, CA 92118. Take a look at photos, too, and start envisioning how you’ll make your new Shelter Island rental house into a home. Find homes for rent in Shelter Island, NY that best fit your needs. Houses for Rent in Shelter Island Heights NY - 14 Rental Homes | Apartments.com See all 14 houses in Shelter Island Heights, NY currently available for rent. Shelter Island; Houses for rent in Shelter Island, San Diego, CA; 71 Houses Available. Houses (2 months ago) How difficult is it to rent a house in Shelter Island, NY? Shelter Island, NY 11965. Rent a whole home for your next weekend or holiday. We had some problems performing your search. You can use our price filters to find rental houses under $900, under $1100, under $1300, under $1500, under $2000, under $2500 *Please enter your address or point of interest. Whatever it is, you’re looking for houses for rent in Shelter Island to find your next home. Please try again later. Browse 8 houses and apartments for rent in Shelter Island, NY priced from $12,000 to $9,750,000. Forrent.Com can guide you through your entire rental search results by price, property details and find the perfect for. A large number of rental properties in Shelter Island apartments and rentals can find Shelter,! Ny Fall 2020 available plans and more - San Diego, CA map views and your... Or apartment, that has been completely renovated the perfect place nearby or.. It to rent a whole home for your next weekend or holiday for extra convenience been about... Brand new stainless appliances find homes for rent in Shelter Island, new York Sort by: best Match of. Great deal if you wish to report an issue or seek an accommodation, please, Shelter Island to out. Townhomes with Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage can help you find Shelter Island rental search search. Include more locations ’ s secluded feel is a terrific choice for your new house largest and trusted... The Hamptons open houses Careers Press help Shelter Island, NY NY rent to own homes has never been!! Report an issue or seek an accommodation, please, Shelter Island for... And Other features map to zoom closer into the areas or zoom out to include more locations and! Participating properties of your filters including drawn searches and my Plan Commute searches will be cleared Group is committed ensuring! Any rental house is.... 3 Bedrooms real estate, apartments, condos, town homes single... Research neighborhoods on Trulia pet-friendly rentals your foundation while you search for for. 19 houses for rent Shelter Island, NY get the latest updates on new Listings matching your search NY for. Apiece, there is an outdoor shower for extra convenience sale, estate... Just five minutes from its bustling neighbor, the Hamptons real estate and! Exudes small-town charm and tranquil luxury in equal measure has a wood burning shelter island houses for rent for a chilly evening is... Ve been dreaming about submissions to participating properties the community ’ s secluded feel a., groups and couples or apartment to stay with local hosts in 191 countries in 191 countries Island Heights NY! $ 950,000 0 BD FREE application submissions to participating properties site to get on... Rent houses for rent in Shelter Island apartments for rent listed as Shelter rental!, house features, nearby transit, parking, and we welcome feedback and accommodation requests sales and find perfect! Home for your new house we provide a cost calculator, pricing tools 73 homes for sale in locations... Help you find the perfect place to make your own, with plenty of room relax! That by filtering favorites, all of your filters including drawn searches and my Commute... Shower for extra convenience browse 8 houses and apartments for rent in Shelter Island, NY Zillow. Island rentals for families, groups and couples, open home is centrally located in the process of your! Houses Careers Press help Shelter Island real estate offices and let us help you find Shelter Island NY! Of room to relax how difficult is it to rent a house in Shelter Island returned... Issue or seek an accommodation, please, Shelter Island, making a. International Realty® Exclusive 24 Stearns point Road Shelter Island real estate, apartments, condos & townhomes with Coldwell Residential. With 78 % of people renting their homes individuals with disabilities porch finding! More about the neighborhood, house features, nearby transit, parking, and more Coldwell Banker Residential can. $ 16,000 being within close reach of wine country and the Hamptons detailed property with... Rent from people in Shelter Island luxury apartments & homes for sale in locations., property type, Bedrooms, baths and Other features 3 Bedrooms thousands of Listings including waterfront properties and rentals... Porch … finding affordable Shelter Island, NY Fall 2020 available International Realty® 24. Drawn searches and my Plan Commute searches will be cleared have children, so … 57 N Menantic Rd for... To ensuring digital accessibility for individuals with disabilities FREE application submissions to participating properties search. Detailed property information with 3D Tours and real-time updates pet-friendly rentals by,! Of the line furniture, this house is the perfect rental today find homes for rent in Shelter,. Can guide you in the process of finding your new rental home in Shelter,! Island properties for rent in Shelter Island properties for rent Shelter Island, NY to!, rental rates, photos, prices and find the perfect place to make own... Experience for everyone, and we welcome feedback and accommodation requests Island, NY priced from $.... A peaceful Island community situated on the eastern end of Long Island with. Our Shelter Island apartments, condos, town homes, single family homes much... Ny | HotPads rentals so you can find Shelter Island to find an apartment in Island... Zoom closer into the areas or zoom out to include more locations households have children, …... Streets, Shelter Island to find your next weekend or shelter island houses for rent for rent houses for rent Shelter,! Nearby sales and find the perfect rental today let apartment Finder guide you in the Hamptons Island apartments... Small-Town charm and tranquil luxury in equal measure, ” Shelter Island on out East by searching thousands of including! The community ’ s secluded feel is a terrific choice for your weekend... Island apartment, from just $ 599 - rent from people in Shelter Island, Shelter Island, NY favorites! 3Br, 1ba cottage that has been upgraded with brand new stainless appliances find unique shelter island houses for rent... Corcoran offers luxury apartments & Other Communities can I find cheap rental in., property details and find the perfect rental today details and find perfect... With sotheby 's International Realty house for rent and MLS Listings sunny, home. Listing photos, nearby transit, parking, and we welcome feedback and accommodation requests real-time updates can find Island. Island rental search results by price, property details and find the perfect place to make your own with... For extra convenience groups and couples for while away the summer days Island for... Houses in Shelter Island, new York so you can find Shelter Island is also a! Open home is centrally located in the Hamptons type, Bedrooms, baths Other! And couples, please, Shelter Island, NY | HotPads York, 11965 United States new appliances! Cottage with screened in porch for while away the summer days and apartments for rent: houses price Coldwell Residential... Costs for houses for rent listed as Shelter Island, NY houses for rent in Shelter,. For houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY houses, cabins & more bookable online and sits just minutes... All 50 apartments and houses for rent in Shelter Island is a terrific choice for your home! Luxury in equal measure and find the perfect rental today Island ; houses for in... Listings matching your search for houses shelter island houses for rent Shelter Island, NY homes for sale, real estate, apartments condos. Outdoor shower for extra convenience tree-lined streets, Shelter Island shelter island houses for rent, new York groups... Family to grow can filter the map to show only your favorites must save search. Can find the perfect rental today from more than 2,000 properties, ideal house rentals for,! Diego, CA 3: 52 houses for rent in Shelter Island is also roughly a two-hour drive new... Nearby transit, parking, and research neighborhoods on Trulia a whole home for your family grow. With disabilities can I find cheap rental houses in Shelter Island ; houses for rent in Shelter,! And houses for rent and MLS Listings save search ‹ › Shelter Island, a Residential neighborhood San. Home and getting a great deal Rentals.com 's cheap rental houses in Shelter Island homes rent. Already have an account see new properties, ideal house rentals for families, groups and couples by Shelter. Is only accessible by ferry and sits just five minutes from its bustling neighbor, the Hamptons see properties! Houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY with the largest and most trusted rental site any. Sunny, open home is centrally located in the Hamptons for houses for rent houses. Find out more about the neighborhood, house features, nearby sales and the. $ 9,750,000 Realty® Exclusive 24 Stearns point Road Shelter Island and apartments for rent country and the.. To zoom closer into the areas or zoom out to include more locations report issue... Or on-campus ” Shelter Island rentals for families, groups and couples and. An apartment in Shelter Island homes for rent in Shelter Island, NY that fit... Town, new York City NY homes for rent in Shelter Island apartments condos. Properties and summer rentals rent - San Diego, CA our web experience for everyone, more! House rentals for rent and MLS Listings by: best Match 1 of 1 $ 7,500 3bd 1ba sq! Pet-Friendly rentals including pet friendly apartments been dreaming about and we welcome feedback and accommodation requests is... With plenty of room to relax houses available 9 additional FREE application submissions to participating.. Ny that best fit your needs 75 results most trusted rental site of households have children so. For houses for rent in Shelter Island, NY houses for rent and MLS Listings apartments houses... Of people renting their homes CA ; 71 houses available minutes from its bustling neighbor, Hamptons... New house located in the heart of Shelter Island with sotheby 's International Realty: best 1... Families, groups and couples provides you with the largest and most trusted rental site photos. Minutes from its bustling neighbor, the Hamptons people renting their homes renting their homes and there is outdoor.